The quiet doctor
Are medical schools doing enough to support their introverted students, and can a quiet doctor excel in medicine?
When Susan Cain wrote her book Quiet: the Power of Introverts in a World that Can’t Stop Talking she had no idea how successful it would become. It was published in 2013 and sold more than two million copies in 30 languages. In the book, she argues that our societal attitudes undervalue and discriminate against the traits of an introverted personality. Her TED talk on the subject, viewed more than 18 million times, has propelled Cain to a level of celebrity even higher than that expected of a New York Times author.
She defines introversion—separable from social anxiety or shyness—as a preference for “quiet concentration, listening rather than talking and thinking before speaking.” Introverts like to spend time alone and enjoy in-depth, one-on-one conversation rather than small talk. Generally, she claims, they have a contemplative, independent, and empathetic character. Extroverts, on the other hand, draw energy from social situations and group settings, enjoy thinking aloud, and thrive when at the centre of attention.
Today Cain runs a project called Quiet Revolution, which aims to rebalance how we think of quiet personalities. The website’s testimonies make it clear that Cain’s repositioning of introversion as a strength rather than a weakness has benefited people from many professions. Examples include a criminal psychologist who credits her acute observations to her introversion, a lawyer who began to take pride in her quietness, and a corporate manager who was promoted after her boss took a gamble on her calm thoughtful approach to leadership.
However, Cain’s quiet revolution seems to have had little effect in medicine. Doctors are usually portrayed in the media as extroverts—just think of the average episode of ER or Grey’s Anatomy. At best they are presented as effervescent, gregarious social butterflies and at worst as twisted entertainers plagued by arrogance and narcissism. Whether eager to embarrass medical students on their ward round or adept at polished small talk, both the positive and negative portrayals of doctors fit into the extrovert stereotype.
Medicine: an extroverted career?
So why do we tend not to think of doctors as introverts; is it just that extroverted personalities are more suited to medicine? Helen Salisbury, a general practitioner who runs the communications skills course for medical students at the University of Oxford, thinks not. She meets “a variety of personality types making successful careers in medicine” and asserts that there is not “one ideal” personality for a doctor. Although introversion “could be seen as a disadvantage if taken to an extreme,” Salisbury argues that introverted students are likely to be “thoughtful and reflective about their role and relationships with patients.”
Megan Riddle graduated from Cornell University Medical School (New York, USA) in 2014. Now a junior psychiatrist, she describes her introverted personality as “invaluable” to her clinical life. Her introverted traits posed challenges throughout medical school, particularly her preference to “develop proficiency in something before being asked to move to the next thing” and “not speaking up unless [having] something to contribute.” She thinks there are “many niches for introverts” in medicine and that the struggle for a medical student to “be out in front, showing what you can do” is largely replaced by the need for consistency, conscientiousness, and an independent work ethic as a practising doctor.
Riddle regards her quiet persona as instrumental in gradually building trust within a team. Sil-Jun Lau, a final year student at Barts and The London School of Medicine, similarly credits his introversion for much of the positive feedback he’s received on communication skills. “Being reserved translates well into being a patient listener, which can get praise,” he summarises.
The idea that introversion can be advantageous to teamwork and leadership has been gaining traction in social science research. Although introversion has never been analysed in the context of medicine, a 2011 paper identified that teams led by extroverts often performed less well than those led by introverts, an effect that was most pronounced when employees were proactive. Although it is unclear whether this trend applies to clinical settings, it is an area that social scientists will probably be keen to investigate soon.
Despite these potential benefits of introversion, Riddle remembers medical school being “stacked in favour of the extrovert,” with rapid fire questioning during ward rounds, endless group activities, and an emphasis on networking to find research opportunities. Nathaniel Fleming, a second year medical student at Stanford School of Medicine (CA, USA), raises similar concerns when discussing the attitudes embodied by the famous medical school adage of “see one, do one, teach one.” Such an approach comes naturally to extrovert personalities, he suggests, but is “jarring for [students] who like to take time for deliberation and reflection.”
Fleming also says that medical school can pose social challenges for quieter students. The “expectation for medical students to be constantly engaged in a conversational way, and to get to know everybody else, rewards the ability to network” he argues, which means other attributes are undervalued. “It starts to feel like it’s just all small talk, all the time; an introvert’s worst nightmare.” Amy, another student, told Student BMJ that she had “found medicine to be quite cliquey.” “Most of the organised events are geared towards more social students, and there’s an assumption that everyone falls into the binge drinking, or work-hard play-hard, stereotype.”
Amy describes how not being in the right friendship group can cause students to be left “out of the loop and miss out on key resources.” This is especially apparent in the run up to exams, where revision resources are passed down by students in the year above.
The challenges introverts face at medical school can also undermine their confidence in their ability to practise medicine. Johnny, a fifth year medical student at the University of Manchester, told Student BMJ that he had questioned whether he could excel as a quiet doctor. “I found myself less willing to put myself forward for things than my extroverted colleagues and wondering whether I could face being the centre of attention for the rest of my career.” These kinds of experiences are probably common, especially as longitudinal studies have found that, throughout medical school, introverted students are at higher risk of stress and burnout than their extroverted colleagues. 
Recommendations for medical schools
Are medical schools doing enough to support their quieter students? Research published in Teaching and Learning in Medicine suggests not. The authors of a 2015 paper lamented “an increasingly negative tone of language associated with introversion,” a problem they believed to be “particularly salient” because of the recent proliferation of interactive and problem based learning techniques in medical schools. The paper recommends “simple strategies to foster the learning of introverts,” such as offering students time to reflect on their answers instead of rapid-fire questioning and organising discussion based teaching in a way that encourages all group members to participate.
The authors also note a “potential bias” in the way that medical students’ abilities are evaluated. According to the paper, introverted students may be disadvantaged by evaluation metrics that disproportionately value extroverted behaviours, such as “willingness to initiate discussion, taking the lead in a group and participation in a session.” Instead, the authors suggest giving more weight to behaviours such as “thinking before speaking, offering a synthesis of information and listening to peers before engaging.” Not only would this assess medical school performance more fairly, they argue, but it would benefit extroverted students by identifying clinically important areas to improve on.
The paper also cautions medical educators to be aware of the difference between introversion and social anxiety. Although “interventions such as increased exposure are useful for anxious individuals,” these same interventions can be counterproductive for non-anxious introverts. The authors conclude that encouraging introverted students to change their personality risks invalidating their perspectives of the world.
It is unclear how these recommendations in the academic literature will be received by medical educators. When responding to the suggestion that medical schools could better cater for their introverted students, Salisbury acknowledged that some activities, such as group work and role plays, are “much harder for some students than others.” Recognising that “the medical consultation is usually a one-to-one interaction,” she sympathises with those who question why medical students are taught in groups. But she argues that the resources for individual tuition are limited, and that peer-to-peer feedback can be a useful teaching tool. Activities like role playing are a “necessary skill whatever your personality” Salisbury concludes, as they form the method of examination in “every medical school and higher professional exam.”
Planning for the future
Although Salisbury’s arguments do not contradict the suggestions made in the literature, the lack of discussion about the specific learning needs of introverted students means that any substantial changes are unlikely in the short term. Given this, it may be tempting for introverted students to look at what steps they can take to improve their experience of medicine.
Many online tools offer this service, by recommending medical specialties on the basis of personality tests such as the Myers-Briggs type indicator. The test classifies students into four dichotomies, one of which is introversion-extroversion. However, the test’s accuracy is questionable. The tool recommends psychiatry as a specialty for introverts, but a 2016 study showed that it had no predict value regarding the choice of this specialty. Caroline Elton, a chartered psychologist who runs a career planning service for doctors, also recommends a nuanced reading of the evidence behind these tests; “personality is more about how you do your specialty, rather than what specialty you do,” she summarised.
At least for now, it seems that many of the immediate challenges facing introverts in medicine are unavoidable. However, it is clear that the hallmarks of introversion—thoughtfulness, an analytical mind, and adept listening skills among others—can equip students with a strong basis for a clinical career. Although these traits might seem to be under-appreciated at medical school, the lessons learnt from junior doctors, researchers, and medical educators suggest that many of today’s introverted students come to view their personality as “a strength rather than a weakness” as their clinical lives progress.George Gillett, fourth year medical student
University of Oxford
Competing interests: None declared.
Provenance and peer review: Commissioned; not externally peer reviewed.
Some of the students in this article chose to be identified by a pseudonym.
- Cain S. Quiet: the power of introverts in a world that can’t stop talking.Penguin Books, 2013.
- Quiet Revolution. Portraits. http://www.quietrev.com/portraits/.
- Grant A, Gino F, Hofmann D. Reversing the extraverted leadership advantage: the role of employee proactivity. Acad Manage J 2011;54:528-50. doi:10.5465/AMJ.2011.61968043.
- Tyssen R, Dolatowski FC, Røvik JO, et al. Personality traits and types predict medical school stress: a six-year longitudinal and nationwide study. Med Educ 2007;41:781-7. doi:10.1111/j.1365-2923.2007.02802.x pmid:17661886.
- McManus IC, Keeling A, Paice E. Stress, burnout and doctors’ attitudes to work are determined by personality and learning style: a twelve year longitudinal study of UK medical graduates. BMC Med 2004;2:29. doi:10.1186/1741-7015-2-29 pmid:15317650.
- Davidson B, Gillies RA, Pelletier AL. Introversion and medical student education: challenges for both students and educators. Teach Learn Med 2015;27:99-104. doi:10.1080/10401334.2014.979183 pmid:25584478.
- Yang C, Richard G, Durkin M. The association between Myers-Briggs Type Indicator and Psychiatry as the specialty choice. Int J Med Educ 2016;7:48-51. doi:10.5116/ijme.5698.e2cd pmid:26851600.